Who Sees the Ads When AI Runs the Internet?

By Ashley Lane5 min read

  • ai
  • advertising
  • attention
  • digital out of home
  • future of media

AI is the ultimate ad blocker.

Not the kind you install in Chrome. The kind that removes the customer from the internet altogether.

Consider how absurd the advertising business is about to become. An agent visits fifty websites, compares a hundred products, reads a thousand reviews and buys the best option. The websites get traffic. The analytics dashboards light up. The advertisers pay for attention. But the only thing looking at those pages is software.

Who exactly is supposed to see the ads?

We have spent the best part of thirty years designing the internet around the human eyeball. Search results wrapped in sponsored listings. News articles buried under banners. Videos interrupted by pre-rolls. Websites engineered to squeeze another second of attention out of visitors who would rather be somewhere else.

And now we are building machines whose entire purpose is to spare us from doing any of that.

A billion visitors. Nobody home.

The next great internet traffic boom might be the least exciting one in advertising history.

Bots used to be something websites tried to keep out. Now we are enthusiastically building agents and giving them credit cards. They will research, compare, negotiate, book and buy. Entire commercial journeys that once involved dozens of human encounters with websites will collapse into one instruction and one result.

A hotel might get its booking without the guest ever seeing its homepage. A retailer might make the sale without anyone browsing its catalogue. A publisher might provide the research for a decision without a single human reading the article.

The internet isn't going away. Quite the opposite. It could become extraordinarily busy. It just won't necessarily be busy with people.

For an industry that has turned human attention into one of the world's largest businesses, that should be a rather uncomfortable thought.

Can you advertise to an AI?

Of course someone will try. In fact, everyone will.

If agents become the new gatekeepers of consumer decisions, there will be an enormous incentive to influence what they recommend. We will have an entirely new industry dedicated to getting brands, products and offers into the context of machines.

Search-engine optimization becomes agent optimization. Sponsored results become sponsored recommendations. Product placement becomes something altogether stranger: paying for a place in the thinking process of software that claims to be acting on your behalf.

But here's the interesting part. The better these assistants become, the less convincing the old advertising tricks should be. An agent doesn't get distracted by a smiling face in a banner. It doesn't impulse-buy because a website used an orange countdown timer. It doesn't need to scroll past six sponsored results to find what it was asked to find.

The advertising industry could spend a fortune trying to persuade machines that were invented to make decisions without being persuaded.

Meanwhile, humans still have eyeballs.

And where are those eyeballs going to be?

In the real world.

In cafés, restaurants, hotels, airports, parks, shops, offices, gyms and thousands of other places where people actually live their lives. Better AI could give us back some of the time we currently waste staring at screens, navigating software and doing digital admin. I would like to think we'll spend at least some of it doing more interesting things.

This makes me think the advertising industry's next big opportunity might be staring us in the face. Quite literally.

Digital out-of-home advertising is about to become a far more interesting business.

The internet taught advertisers to follow us around online. AI may force them to rethink how to meet us where we are physically. But I hope the response isn't simply to stick an illuminated rectangle onto every available wall.

Please don't turn the real world into the internet.

Most advertising screens are ugly. There, I've said it.

Too bright. Too loud. Too obviously designed to extract attention rather than add anything to the place they're occupying. A giant glowing billboard might be impressive the first time you see it, but it isn't my idea of a more beautiful city.

We've already let the internet become an obstacle course of pop-ups, autoplay videos and sponsored interruptions. The last thing we should do is recreate that experience in our streets, cafés and homes.

The opportunity is to think about these surfaces in an entirely different way.

Imagine information beautifully integrated into furniture, architecture and everyday objects. Displays that are useful when you need them, almost invisible when you don't. A café table that shows something delightful. A hotel lobby that feels more alive. A shop window that responds to its surroundings. Local information, useful services, art, entertainment and, occasionally, a commercial message so relevant to the moment that it belongs there.

And yes, these would still be connected to the internet. The shift isn't away from connectivity. It's away from making the smartphone or browser the compulsory interface between a person and the digital world.

The best advertising network of the future might not look like an advertising network at all.

The next scarce resource isn't traffic.

We're heading toward an era in which producing content becomes almost free, generating websites becomes trivial and sending autonomous agents across the internet becomes routine.

Traffic may be abundant. Content may be infinite. Digital interactions may be counted in the trillions.

But actual human attention? That is still finite.

And I suspect it is about to become much more valuable.

The companies that win won't necessarily be those with the most websites, the cleverest tracking pixels or the largest inventory of flashing rectangles. They may be the ones that find beautiful, useful and welcome ways to be part of the physical moments people choose to spend their time in.

AI is the ultimate ad blocker. And it might turn out to be the biggest opportunity physical media has ever had.

All articles